Improvements to UK retail banking market are missing the mark

Improvements to UK retail banking market are missing the mark

Alex Kwiatkowski

Senior Strategist for Banking and Digital Channels at Misys

Views 566

Improvements to UK retail banking market are missing the mark

06.06.2016 03:30 pm

After a two-year investigation, the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has published provisional recommendations to improve retail banking in the UK. It’s a sector that requires remedial attention, but once again a golden opportunity to radically transform the existing market has been shunned in favour of a less far-reaching set of target outcomes. It mirrors the same timid way the Independent Commission on Banking (ICB) balked at proposing wide-ranging structural and non-structural reforms to the wider banking sector back in 2011. But could we really have expected more? On balance, and with the recent history of government-mandated bank surgery as a guide, ‘no probably not’ is the inevitable – and disappointing – answer.

The CMA suggests that banks should set a monthly maximum charge for unarranged overdrafts on current accounts, and send an alert to customers prior to them slipping into the red so they can avoid being penalised. Not a terrible idea, but not a terrific one either.

The latest figures from the BBA suggest that total overdraft lending stands at £6.9bn (as of March 2016). The FCA previously estimated that 90 per cent of this debt is authorised, and so we’re looking at an unauthorised amount of circa £690m per month. That’s big business, as the penalty fees generated by unauthorised use is a significant income stream for the UK’s banks, and so imposing a maximum limit will simultaneously impact upon revenue.

However, let’s not play a sympathetic violin solo for the banking industry (or customers for that matter). Instead, let’s concentrate on achieving beneficial outcomes beyond the CMA’s recommendations. For instance, increased digitalisation can undoubtedly have a positive impact. Greater use of personal financial management (PFM) tools can help customers better manage their finances, and ideally avoid going overdrawn in the first place by monitoring incomings, outgoings and understanding what’s ‘safe to spend’.

Returning to the provisional report, the CMA appears content to let account holders seek out bargain products. Alongside their overdraft recommendations comes a drive towards the implementation of new online comparison tools, improvements to the account switching service, and the requirement for banks to regularly engage with customers to ensure they are getting value for money. These moves are pragmatic but uninspiring. They will also do next to nothing to loosen the grip that the UK’s biggest banks have on the market. Stimulating competition looks just as hard a task as ever.

Let’s pause for a moment to consider account switching. Introduced in a blaze of consumer-friendly publicity and at an eye-wateringly high cost to the industry – circa £500m was spent in preparation – the service has recorded disappointing levels of activity since it was launched in 2013. Of the approximately 65m personal current accounts held in the UK, 2,819,445 have been switched. To put it another way, that’s 4.3 per cent of the total, or £177 per switch. In the value for money stakes, this doesn’t look like a sure-fire winner.

The ICB surely didn’t envisage such an embarrassingly meagre adoption rate when they made the strategic recommendation to introduce switching, and with the CMA missing this opportunity to be bold, it’s hard to see how this glacial pace of development is ever going to accelerate. Customers are aware of account switching, but they’re just not sufficiently enamoured with the arguments for change. A clear case of better the devil you know, and persuading account holders that the grass might grow sufficiently greener on the other side to justify switching remains a big hurdle to overcome.

Viewing developments through a technological lens, the CMA wants to see the swift introduction of an open API banking standard to help with account comparison and switching for personal and SME customers. This will enable account holders to “safely and securely share their transaction history with other banks and trusted third parties”. It’s pleasing to see that opening-up previously ‘closed’ banking systems is being recommended, but thought must be given to the impact for banks. In practice, it will require banks to ensure data can be accessed easily, necessitating a thorough tidying-up of the data warehouse shelves. It will also demand the provision of requisite layers of security to protect sensitive systems from the unwanted attention of cyber-criminals who relentlessly seek to exploit vulnerabilities in defences.

The proof of the pudding is always in the eating. The CMA’s recipe looks bland. The final report will be published by August 12 2016. There’s still time to add a touch of spice between now and then.

Latest blogs

Thomas Pintelon Capilever

Credit origination - A lot of innovation on the horizon

While consumer credits are becoming more automated and user-friendly to request, all other credits are often still very manual and labor intensive to originate. In this (relatively long) blog I will try to give a description of the (potentially Read more »

Kelly Kearsley

Time Card Theft is a Big Problem. Here's How to Stop It.

Trust is at the core of every employer-employee relationship. You trust your people to do their jobs, and they trust you to compensate them for their work. Most of the time, it works. However, there's always the person looking to bend the rules or Read more »

Daria Afanasyeva UTP Merchant Services Ltd

Cybersecurity – Online payments are getting more secure

Ever since we've been able to buy anything we need with just a click of a button on our laptops or phones, online sales have been consistently increasing each year. Just last year, the total value of UK retail sales was £394 billion, with an average Read more »

James McGivern Cashfac

Keeping Honest Payment Service Institutions Honest

Following the collapse of Wirecard, James McGivern, Head of NBFI at Cashfac, reinforces the need for operational accounting and reconciliation in eMoney and Payment Service Providers The other day an ex-colleague reminded me that we had tried to Read more »

Orion Hindawi Tanium

New Salesforce Partnership and Investment in Tanium Reimagines Employee Service Management in an Increasingly Remote-Working World

We are excited to announce a strategic partnership with Salesforce, supported by a new round of funding led by a strategic investment from Salesforce Ventures to reimagine employee service management, bringing the company’s post-money valuation to $ Read more »

Related Blogs

Chris Skinner The Financial Services Club

Top 10 Retail Banking Trends for 2017

I kept yesterday’s blog entry short because I knew that today’s was long, and it’s a guest blog entry from my good friend Jim Marous.  Jim produces a great report each year, curating the thoughts of 100 industry leaders including myself, on what is Read more »

James Clark Wipro Digital

The CMA’s Retail Banking Market Investigation: What Happens Next?

The CMA’s Retail Banking Market Investigation is over 700 pages, with the summary clocking in at 52 pages. Before you dive in, here are the key takeaways from the report: Read more »

Gary Fegan Fujitsu Digital

"Within a Decade Retail Banking will be Dead" - I Don't Think So

I’ve just read an article titled “Within a Decade, Retail Banks will be Dead”, at the time of reading, it had 2517 likes and 697 comments on LinkedIn. As a result, I assumed this must be great stuff. But instead, after reading, I was left slightly Read more »

Bruce Jennings FIS

Banking’s next blind spot: innovation for innovation’s sake

Retail banking is under pressure from every angle. Technological advances, and the evolving attitudes they shape, have lowered the barriers to entry for new challengers and rendered ‘legacy systems’ a competitive disadvantage for the established Read more »

Will White investUP

Retail money must stay in crowdfunding

There’s a curious “truth” doing the rounds in the peer-to-peer sector. It goes something like this: Institutional money has arrived in crowdfunding big time. This is a fantastic endorsement of this growing sector. The future will be more Read more »

Free Newsletter Sign-up
+44 (0) 208 819 32 53 +44 (0) 173 261 71 47
Download Our Mobile App
Financial It Youtube channel