The CMA’s Retail Banking Market Investigation: What Happens Next?

The CMA’s Retail Banking Market Investigation: What Happens Next?

James Clark

Practice Partner – Digitization and Automation at Wipro Digital

Views 580

The CMA’s Retail Banking Market Investigation: What Happens Next?

23.08.2016 09:30 am

The CMA’s Retail Banking Market Investigation is over 700 pages, with the summary clocking in at 52 pages. Before you dive in, here are the key takeaways from the report:

  • The overall level of account switching between banks is low because most of the banks are perceived as being of equally poor quality
  • The banks consider the most profitable customers to be those with lots of money, but who are bad at managing it, and buy expensive packages of add-ons
  • The customers that banks want to keep are those who use unauthorised overdrafts but have enough money to pay them back, along with the related fees
  • Customers need to smarten up and listen to what their bank is telling them in order to avoid heavy charges
  • Unauthorised overdrafts are not too expensive, but banks must tell their customers clearly how much they cost and warn them when approaching the “red”

None of these findings are new or surprising

Nice of the CMA to spend £5 million on a market analysis and customer segmentation exercise for the banks and to tell them what APIs and mobile apps they need to deliver over the next 18 months.

This is a great result for the banks, especially the Top 5. The potential downside was considerable – unauthorised overdraft rates could have been capped. Thanks to significant lobbying, the CMA has left pricing alone and favoured a route of improved transparency and communication. This means that it can still be cheaper to borrow from Wonga than the high street, but one must be careful of the consequences of not repaying promptly.

The CMA also has not required banks to make principle account numbers portable. This would have been truly expensive, because most banks are still running core systems based on products rather than customers. This is a lost opportunity to confront banks with the need to modernise for the digital age.

Furthermore, there has already been lobbying for extending the timetable for delivery of the remedies, in particular the implementation of open APIs. Excuses made have been the implementation of UK Ring fenced banks, the implementation of PSD2, and the use of cheque imaging, to name a few. Frankly, this is not good enough.

It’s all about prioritising spending. Should it be on bonuses and dividends or on real IT investment to promote an active and competitive market? I know what I think the answer is and I’m sure I’m not alone.

What’s next? Re-imagining banking approachability

Let’s look at the customer. This is an instance where technology really can help and will have an increasingly user-friendly interface. Using mainstream techniques or APIs, long-time perfected and up-to-date with Facebook, Uber and the other Digital Lighthouses, customers will be able to research, try, select and commit to the best propositions for them.

Customers will be able to have confidence that their future banking partner will grant them an overdraft – one of the major reasons for not switching is uncertainty whether existing facilities will be offered by a new provider. They will be able to simulate costs based on historic and future data to give meaningful results. They will find familiar characters – meerkats and opera singers – offering comparisons for bank accounts just as they do for car insurance today. The process of switching accounts will become more “friendly” and the overall level of confidence in a hassle-free experience will grow.

Tablets and phones will become the norm for everyday banking. Bank branches will still be important, but the role of the staff inside them will concentrate more on education, advice, guidance and support in resolving problems or more complex financial transactions.

There will be an industry shakeup

Banking institutions, big and small, that move quickly and take risks to anticipate these changes will thrive. They will be sought out by customers, whatever their status or potential, who want more from their banks. Behaviour and experience will become the critical levers that define social and financial success on the financial high street.

Technology will enable banks to assess customers, their worth and risk, in new ways. Already some lending institutions are using social media and other technology-based factors as data points for assessing risk and potential. What happened in the past – “Credit History” – will stay relevant, but the data that is now more important is what helps predict future activity. Data and analytics will become the currency and measurement of success and desirability.

Customer experience will lead the way

So the future is bright for financial services providers – do we need to call them banks any more – who move fast and stay focused on their customers’ needs and desires. Bright for those who know how to manage their technology and the money they spend on it.

Not so bright for those who are still wrestling with a decade of “technology debt,” and for those who spend most of their budget on keeping the IT lights on, and for those who think life would be much simpler if they had fewer customers to worry about – that is certainly a self-fulfilling prophesy.

And the best role of all for banks? To be an IT services provider with real-end-to end capability to help the financial ecosystem survive and thrive with incumbents, start-ups, other technology firms, and consumer focused brands.


Latest blogs

N/A ReliaMax

College Dreams? Here’s How to Get Accepted

Higher education in the United States is not just about getting accepted, it is about where you get accepted. Sure, there are options, there are seemingly endless options - from community colleges to Ivy League schools and everything in between. The Read more »

Bobby Gill GCWealth

Bobby Gill: 3 Ways Fintech is Helping Small Businesses During the Pandemic

Image Source: Pixabay. Back in April, the US oil prices sank to a 20-year low. In the UK, road traffic levels hit a 70-year low. Worldwide, due to lockdown, retail, travel, and restaurant bookings have dropped by 85%. More than 430 million Read more »

Christa Ardley Bitstocks

Bitcoin and blockchain without the b******t

An industry once viewed by the general populace as a haven for criminals and online scammers, and still somewhat marred by fractious in-fighting, Bitcoin and blockchain are gradually casting off their outdated negative reputation; as the focus Read more »

Otabek Nuritdinov Safenetpay

Beyond Payments Services

    Why it really matters for small for medium-sized enterprise (SMEs) to choose the right payments services provider. Strategic planners in the financial services sector often define their business in terms of products that Read more »

Chak Kolli DXC Technology

How Can Insurers Realise the True Value of AI?

As Artificial Intelligence (AI) and digital transformation find their way into every aspect of our daily lives, we are gradually seeing changes taking place in different sectors. Progressively, AI is permeating the insurance value chain and it is Read more »

Related Blogs

Chris Skinner The Financial Services Club

Top 10 Retail Banking Trends for 2017

I kept yesterday’s blog entry short because I knew that today’s was long, and it’s a guest blog entry from my good friend Jim Marous.  Jim produces a great report each year, curating the thoughts of 100 industry leaders including myself, on what is Read more »

Gary Fegan Fujitsu Digital

"Within a Decade Retail Banking will be Dead" - I Don't Think So

I’ve just read an article titled “Within a Decade, Retail Banks will be Dead”, at the time of reading, it had 2517 likes and 697 comments on LinkedIn. As a result, I assumed this must be great stuff. But instead, after reading, I was left slightly Read more »

Alex Kwiatkowski Misys

Improvements to UK retail banking market are missing the mark

After a two-year investigation, the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has published provisional recommendations to improve retail banking in the UK. It’s a sector that requires remedial attention, but once again a golden opportunity to Read more »

Bruce Jennings FIS

Banking’s next blind spot: innovation for innovation’s sake

Retail banking is under pressure from every angle. Technological advances, and the evolving attitudes they shape, have lowered the barriers to entry for new challengers and rendered ‘legacy systems’ a competitive disadvantage for the established Read more »

James Tuckett investUP

The crowdISA will be the crowdfunding game-changer

With the return of the Conservatives to government many of their policies will see a ‘business as usual’ banner hoisted above them. Last year the Chancellor made a potentially game-changing commitment to include crowdfunding within the ISA wrapper. Read more »

Free Newsletter Sign-up
+44 (0) 208 819 32 53 +44 (0) 173 261 71 47
Download Our Mobile App
Financial It Youtube channel