"Within a Decade Retail Banking will be Dead" - I Don't Think So

Gary Fegan

Financial Services Solutions at Fujitsu Digital

Views 849

"Within a Decade Retail Banking will be Dead" - I Don't Think So

23.08.2016 08:00 am

I’ve just read an article titled “Within a Decade, Retail Banks will be Dead”, at the time of reading, it had 2517 likes and 697 comments on LinkedIn. As a result, I assumed this must be great stuff. But instead, after reading, I was left slightly bewildered by the title, for what the article was trying to say was retail branches will be dead within 10 years. Then in the comments (not that I read all 697) there was discussion about how retail banking as we know it now will change. Again that still missed the point. Yes, the services that banks will offer will inevitably change, but the fundamentals of retail banking wont.

Now I don’t want to critique the article, but what it did was highlight a few problems within the Fintech bubble; these include:

  • There are a lot of people building cool things that don’t know anything about banking;
  • There are even more cool people commenting on Fintech that know even less about banking;
  • There is a very narrow view of the customer profile.

So an article with so many likes that can’t differentiate between retail banking and branches highlights point 1 and point 2; and I agree that a fresh pair of eyes is exactly what the banking sector needs. At the end of the day, however, it’s still banking, and subject matter knowledge will be required at some point (when dealing with banks and bankers for instance).

Contrary to the original article’s title, retail banking is set for a huge increase. New digital innovations like bitcoin promise to bring banking to the billions of people currently unbanked, and while how we use banking services and how and where we choose to make payments is changing, there will still be a need for retail banks (though they may not necessarily be the present incumbents).

Then there is the last point, an assumption that the customer is just like the author. This customer is tech savvy and trusts electronic transfer of information, likes the convenience of mobile applications, and is of high intellect and wealth and with no disabilities. Now this may be 90% of the finance blog reading population and 99.9% of the Fintech circles, but it doesn’t reflect society as a whole. It doesn’t even cover the “millennial” either, my daughter is 19 and doesn’t use a banking application on her phone.

I can understand this stereotypical oversight because it’s also rife within the banking sector. While branches indeed cost money to own, facilitate, staff, and run, they also provide a useful and necessary function to a lot of sectors of society. Not everyone understands or wants to understand internet and mobile banking, nor can everyone use it for a number of reasons. The rush to close branches and have centralised coffee bars and learning centres may look good on paper in the push to a digital engagement but in adopting this strategy, many banks are actually destroying the only differentiation they have to the challenger banks, and that’s the bricks and mortar branches and their staff.

There is a comfort in knowing that whichever town or city you visit you can pop into a local branch. There is the reassurance that a friendly member of staff can talk you through the fine print and give advice on the best products and services for each customer. Sure, for most people likely to read this, AI “robo-advisors” automatically making the best choices to where your money should be located or predicting your next best decision will be welcome and warmly embraced, but it won’t be for everyone.

I think the high street banks, in a rush to save costs, could be killing off their crown jewels. By removing their signage from the streets where we live, they will also remove their brand from our subconscious.  Think back to why you opened your first bank account, it was probably because it was the closest branch to your house – or, like me, the prospect of picking up a free “super saver squirrel” badge.

I agree whole heartedly that Retail Banking needs to digitise and “think outside the bank” in terms of services and products, but this shouldn’t be at the expense of the retail branch network. The writing is on the wall in terms of further consolidation of banks. The closing of even more branches, but along with creating an intuitive, secure, and frictionless (and also sterile) digital interface, should make traditional banks think about also differentiating themselves in terms of face to face customer service, and that can only be achieved through a retail branch network.

Again though, banks needn’t be confined to the branch. By increasing community work in schools, further education, citizen’s advice centres, or holding workshops and seminars, retail banks can win the hearts and minds of their customers and create a whole different kind of community from the challenger application only banks.

Latest blogs

Shuvo G. Roy Mphasis

Reboot 1.0: How financial services technology can enable the supply chain to support a post-lockdown boom

Ground control and Captain Tom When veteran Captain Tom Moore decided to walk one hundred laps of his garden before his 100th birthday to raise funds to support NHS heroes battling Covid-19 from the frontline, he never imagined that he would Read more »

Lisa Gutu Salt Edge

Building a PSD2 compliant channel: challenges and opportunities for financial institutions

PSD2 obliges ASPSPs including banks, e-wallets, prepaid cards and other companies that offer payment accounts to provide at least one channel for secure communication with third party providers (TPP). Even neobanks or e-money institutions, including Read more »

Thomas Pintelon Capilever

Credit origination - A lot of innovation on the horizon

While consumer credits are becoming more automated and user-friendly to request, all other credits are often still very manual and labor intensive to originate. In this (relatively long) blog I will try to give a description of the (potentially Read more »

Kelly Kearsley Hourly.io

Time Card Theft is a Big Problem. Here's How to Stop It.

Trust is at the core of every employer-employee relationship. You trust your people to do their jobs, and they trust you to compensate them for their work. Most of the time, it works. However, there's always the person looking to bend the rules or Read more »

Daria Afanasyeva UTP Merchant Services Ltd

Cybersecurity – Online payments are getting more secure

Ever since we've been able to buy anything we need with just a click of a button on our laptops or phones, online sales have been consistently increasing each year. Just last year, the total value of UK retail sales was £394 billion, with an average Read more »

Related Blogs

Chris Skinner The Financial Services Club

Top 10 Retail Banking Trends for 2017

I kept yesterday’s blog entry short because I knew that today’s was long, and it’s a guest blog entry from my good friend Jim Marous.  Jim produces a great report each year, curating the thoughts of 100 industry leaders including myself, on what is Read more »

James Clark Wipro Digital

The CMA’s Retail Banking Market Investigation: What Happens Next?

The CMA’s Retail Banking Market Investigation is over 700 pages, with the summary clocking in at 52 pages. Before you dive in, here are the key takeaways from the report: Read more »

Alex Kwiatkowski Misys

Improvements to UK retail banking market are missing the mark

After a two-year investigation, the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has published provisional recommendations to improve retail banking in the UK. It’s a sector that requires remedial attention, but once again a golden opportunity to Read more »

Bruce Jennings FIS

Banking’s next blind spot: innovation for innovation’s sake

Retail banking is under pressure from every angle. Technological advances, and the evolving attitudes they shape, have lowered the barriers to entry for new challengers and rendered ‘legacy systems’ a competitive disadvantage for the established Read more »

Will White investUP

Retail money must stay in crowdfunding

There’s a curious “truth” doing the rounds in the peer-to-peer sector. It goes something like this: Institutional money has arrived in crowdfunding big time. This is a fantastic endorsement of this growing sector. The future will be more Read more »

Free Newsletter Sign-up
+44 (0) 208 819 32 53 +44 (0) 173 261 71 47
Download Our Mobile App
Financial It Youtube channel