Financial Services — Between Industries or Lost in an Ecosystem?

Financial Services — Between Industries or Lost in an Ecosystem?

Mikko Helin

Director of Business Development at Tieto Financial Services

Views 455

Financial Services — Between Industries or Lost in an Ecosystem?

28.12.2016 11:15 am

Industry barriers are increasingly fading away, and established industry players have gone into new areas. No longer can one company alone provide the experience consumers expect, which has led to the emergence of business ecosystems. Companies in the financial services sector have great potential for gaining strong positions in their ecosystems — but first they need to capture a bigger slice of each customer’s life, or they risk losing their current business to other companies that will.

As new disruptive players, free-of-charge digital services and increasing competition erodes customer bases and revenues, many financial and insurance companies are carefully considering their strategies going forward.

Traditional industry leaders are weakening and merging with others. We have already seen multiple initiatives in which retailers have established their own banking businesses. Some of them have even leapfrogged to insurance as well. A great example of this is the Swedish retailer ICA, which launched its own insurance business in 2015. Meanwhile, insurance companies have moved very close to private healthcare, going so far as to develop their own hospital chain like OP has done in Finland. Inevitably, companies are moving into new domains to fight for the attention of customers and new revenue sources.

One of the most topical approaches for adapting to these new circumstances is Ecosystem Thinking — this means partnering with other companies to innovate and create premium customer value. Across the Nordics, we see plenty of strategic movement towards building ecosystems, and it is even crossing the borders of traditional industries. 

What to consider when entering the world of ecosystems

Functional ecosystems are not easy to create, as they require multiple players to move in the same direction at the same time. If that coordination does not happen, then a reverse domino effect can occur, in which no company is leading the way — with chaotic results. However, financial service providers should certainly explore ecosystems, or they risk losing their current business to another provider that will.

When planning for your role within an ecosystem or network, some fundamental questions must be answered:

1.   Who is the leader of the ecosystem? Is it me or shall I find my role in an ecosystem set up by someone else?

2.   What is my revenue logic? How, when and from whom will I earn my future revenues? Will I win the customer’s heart (i.e. account) or do I need to stay behind another player that has a firmer grip on regular customer interactions?

3.   How do I justify my existence as part of the ecosystem? What can I bring to the table so that the other ecosystem actors feel I am essential? 

Financial services need to capture a bigger slice of the customer’s life

Companies in the financial services domain have good potential for establishing strong positions in ecosystems. Simply put, we are important to broad masses of customers. We handle daily money flows, we optimize personal savings and pensions, and we even insure all the physical belongings of individuals — including their health and lives. What could possibly be more compelling?

However, domains like media, entertainment, retail (i.e. supermarkets) and telecom easily outperform financial services in emotional appeal and intimacy. This leads to a frightening question — should financial services find new roles in the background, delivering their offerings through partnered media or retail companies?

Hopefully not. 

But to avoid such a disturbing scenario, financial service providers must establish a better and more holistic grip on their customers. We need to develop new ways to capture a bigger slice of each customer’s life, rather than just providing stand-alone home loans or car insurance policies. Our industry sits on top of a great abundance of critical customer insight and several unavoidable moments of truth. Perhaps bundling the very fundamental areas of life into one source of value — including money, savings, belongings, health, safety and life — itself would fit the bill. If these holistic offerings do not crystallize as a compelling value proposition for the customer, then what will?

This article originally appeared on

Latest blogs

Ian Johnson Marqeta

UK finance finds that 7.4 million in UK living "almost cashless" lives

These findings show that even before COVID-19 struck, digital banking was increasing exponentially. As more people adopt online and mobile banking, the demand for greater personalisation, flexibility and value that consumers expect from their Read more »

Ian Bradbury Fujitsu UK

UK Finance's UK Payment Markets Report - Comment from Fujitsu

Over the past months, businesses have had to rapidly move away from physical cash in order to provide consumers with a safer service. However, this data shows us that a gradual movement away from cash in society started long before the Read more »

James Turner Turner Little

Protecting yourself against a recession

The coronavirus outbreak has spread to businesses, leaving many around the world counting costs. Notoriously, known as the Great Lockdown, it’s been affecting the world economy since early this year. The predicted recession is considered to be the Read more »

Alan Cole JHC Financial

Every Cloud: Covid-19 and the opportunity for digital transformation

Faced with tighter regulations and changing customer needs, over the last decade Wealth Managers have not had it easy – but with the development of new technologies, many have been able to create efficiencies, reduce costs and shrink operational Read more »

Nabeel Irshad Mastercard

Two sides of the same coin: Financial and digital inclusion

The issue of how to tackle financial inclusion has long been a part of the conversation in banking and financial services circles. Regulations have ledto the UK’s biggest banks having to provide ‘basic bank accounts’ to cater for those who do not Read more »

Related Blogs

Alex Malyshev

How to Apply For Electronic Money Institution License and Payment Institution License In Lithuania

As a supplier of core payments and transaction engine software, knows what difficulties our customers face in the process of applying for an Electronic Money Institution License and Payment Institution License In Lithuania. So we decided Read more »

Gemma Doswell Paybase

Paybase Predicts...

What we said in 2018 Read more »

Mark Grainger Engage Hub

Banking on change: what’s next for the financial services sector in 2020?

2019 has been the year of disruption for the Financial Services (FS) sector, largely driven by evolving customer expectations and the influx of new technology. Increasing regulatory requirements, combined with new entrants in the market and shifting Read more »

Tim Hooley Red Hat

Red Hat 2020 Trends: Financial Services x Technology

Whilst we talk about legacy technology as if it is commonplace across industries, it’s a relatively new term within Financial Services. The financial services industry didn’t used to compete by innovating for customers, instead they relied on Read more »

Alan Donnelly Salesforce

Financial Services Trends 2020

The financial services industry is starting to wake up to the idea of ecosystems and partnerships between challengers and traditional banks. In the coming year we will see the discussion evolve from old vs new and see real-world examples of Read more »

Free Newsletter Sign-up
+44 (0) 208 819 32 53 +44 (0) 173 261 71 47
Download Our Mobile App
Financial It Youtube channel