Is Facebook’s Libra the next PayPal?

 Is Facebook’s Libra the next PayPal?

Chris Skinner

Chairman at The Financial Services Club

Views 664

Is Facebook’s Libra the next PayPal?

30.04.2020 12:45 pm

What if we make money truly global, stable and secure? That’s Libra’s ambition and I’ve got to hand it to the guys at Libra. Having announced their idea to create a global currency last summer, and then see it ripped to pieces by regulators, they’re back.

Yes, it’s Libra 2.0.

What’s the difference between 1.0 and 2.0?

Well, I would summarise it but Barry Eichengreen, Professor of Economics and Political Science at the University of California, does a good job here:

White Paper v2.0 replaces, or more precisely supplements, the original basket-based stablecoin with a set of single-currency stablecoins.  More consequentially, it seeks to address a range of regulatory concerns.  “Anyone,” including law enforcement, will be able to “audit the accuracy of all operations.”  Libra Reserve, made up of cash and short-term securities that serve as stablecoin backing, will be held by a “geographically distributed network of well-capitalized custodian banks.”  Only Designated Dealers (DDs) who “commit to making markets with tight spreads” will interface with both the Libra Association on one side and Libra users on the other.  DDs, we are assured, will be “regulated, well-capitalized financial institutions.”

On the consumer-facing side, DDs will interact mainly with Virtual Asset Service Providers (VASPs), large entities that provide financial services to end users.  VASPs will be regulated, although by whom is not clear, and will have to comply with the anti-money laundering and anti-terrorist finance requirements of the Financial Action Task Force, the relevant standard-setting body. 

All well and good but, as Barry points out, there are still many issues to resolve around money supply, seigniorage, capital buffers, lender of last resort and more.

My own take is that you have to applaud that they’re not giving up. I love the idea of a global digital currency, backed by a basked of national currencies tagged to the G20. I hate the idea of a currency system organised by Facebook, as do most regulators.

Will this amended version work?

I’m not sure. If you read Barry’s post, it is clear that it still has a way to go and, by the time it gets there, The Financial Times claims it’s just another Paypal:

Firstly, instead of creating a single new currency, Libra plans to launch a series of different digital coins, each backed by a different government currency one for one. At a stroke, the association has abandoned its attempts to create a floating digital currency that could even have rivalled the dollar.

Secondly, Libra is scrapping its ambitions to move to a “permissionless” system, whereby anybody could help run the network, and no single authority would have control, as was the original vision of bitcoin. 

Thirdly, the association that runs the coin will now vet any wallet that is launched on the network, and beef up its own scrutiny of what is happening there, rather than leaving it to local regulators.

So what is Libra today?

An idea. It’s just an idea. In fact, if you were a gambler, you’d probably bet on bitcoin as an idea more than Libra, and I wouldn’t bet on bitcoin as an idea. So no, I wouldn’t bet on Libra either, especially after Visa, MasterCard, PayPal, Stripe and others walked away due to the regulatory pressure.

In fact, that regulatory pressure – which was totally predictable – will continue until Libra becomes just a transaction system based upon national currencies and tied to all the regulatory requirements of existing payment systems … just like Paypal.

The article was originally published on thefinanser.com

Latest blogs

Ian Johnson Marqeta

UK finance finds that 7.4 million in UK living "almost cashless" lives

These findings show that even before COVID-19 struck, digital banking was increasing exponentially. As more people adopt online and mobile banking, the demand for greater personalisation, flexibility and value that consumers expect from their Read more »

Ian Bradbury Fujitsu UK

UK Finance's UK Payment Markets Report - Comment from Fujitsu

Over the past months, businesses have had to rapidly move away from physical cash in order to provide consumers with a safer service. However, this data shows us that a gradual movement away from cash in society started long before the Read more »

James Turner Turner Little

Protecting yourself against a recession

The coronavirus outbreak has spread to businesses, leaving many around the world counting costs. Notoriously, known as the Great Lockdown, it’s been affecting the world economy since early this year. The predicted recession is considered to be the Read more »

Alan Cole JHC Financial

Every Cloud: Covid-19 and the opportunity for digital transformation

Faced with tighter regulations and changing customer needs, over the last decade Wealth Managers have not had it easy – but with the development of new technologies, many have been able to create efficiencies, reduce costs and shrink operational Read more »

Nabeel Irshad Mastercard

Two sides of the same coin: Financial and digital inclusion

The issue of how to tackle financial inclusion has long been a part of the conversation in banking and financial services circles. Regulations have ledto the UK’s biggest banks having to provide ‘basic bank accounts’ to cater for those who do not Read more »

Magazine
ALL
Free Newsletter Sign-up
+44 (0) 208 819 32 53 +44 (0) 173 261 71 47
Download Our Mobile App
Financial It Youtube channel