Despite recriminations, the UK Government is far from faultless over Visa crash

Jens Bader

co-founder at MuchBetter

Views 1077

Despite recriminations, the UK Government is far from faultless over Visa crash

12.06.2018 10:30 am

On Friday 1st June, an undisclosed ‘hardware issue’ at Visa left millions of people unable to pay for goods and services in the UK and across Europe. A cross-party group of MPs has since spoken out and demanded answers from Visa, but it begs the questions as to whether now might be a good time for the Government and regulators to do a bit of soul searching too. Surely they must also take some portion of the blame for letting this situation come to pass. No successful business would allow a single point of failure in such a critical area of their operations, why should Government be any different?

The fact of the matter is that the UK Government has an active role and responsibility to supply the UK market with financial tender. Yet it has allowed an outside corporation to establish a monopoly on UK payments. Indeed, up to 80% of all card-present transactions in the UK are authorised on Visa cards with, a volume surpassing cash transactions by far. This complete reliance on a single payment option is definitely a bit short-sighted by people, and you could even argue that the Visa outage should be considered an issue of national security such is its importance. Ultimately we’ve put all our eggs into this one basket with Visa, with not enough thought as to how it is protected.

This problem all stems from the fact that card schemes are not state owned nor backed by any government. This meant that the UK Government was virtually powerless to intervene or help its citizens. In the end, we all had to wait for Visa to come in and fix the problem, and those affected may not be adequately compensated, if at all. We also have to ask ourselves what role and intervention could be expected from the regulators? In most cases, the T&Cs attached to cards ensure that Visa et al have no liability in these kinds of scenarios. Users have no rights and if the system goes down, no matter the consequences, there is no coverage, no indemnification.

More worrying still is that, since we still don’t know the root cause, we also have to accept that this could happen again. It could also be even worse should we continue on our current trajectory towards contactless, further replacing cash payments with plastic.

In the UK, we often think of a cashless society as being a utopian ideal for us to strive towards, but I think this incident reminds us that this vision is not as altruistic as it may seem. You can argue that it is a more convenient way to pay, but we should also remember that the majority of people and businesses promoting the formation of a cashless society have a vested interest in creating one. It is they who stand to gain the most. Card schemes like Visa certainly stand to make more money as people use plastic and contactless more often.

There’s no stopping the continued rise of contactless, but I think we need to ensure that we don’t become over reliant on it – else incidents like this could bring the economy to a virtual standstill. We should also remember that cash is the most universal form of payment, with no barriers to entry or use. While they serve different purposes and may be preferred by different users, a healthy balance of different payment options makes for a healthy payments ecosystem.  

Latest blogs

Avi Starodubsky MoneyNetint

How Can Merchants utilize Blockchain based Payments Technology to expand to new markets and increase revenue?

"Ninety percent of what we see today won’t exist in 10 years’ time, but 10 percent of it will change the world" - Chris Larsen, Ripple's CEO. This statement might be the summary of it all. The world is constantly changing, and with this change, new Read more »

Wayne Johnson encompass corporation

The rise of the KYC Utility: How to plan for success

Successful compliance and risk management programmes within financial institutions depend on effective Know Your Customer (KYC) processes yet most have found these processes to be increasingly onerous, both in terms of time and cost.  This is Read more »

Paul Petta mastercard

Free Trials Without The Hassle

No one wants to be unsatisfied with a product after paying for it. For some consumers, a free-trial is a great way to test out a new product and get comfortable with it before making a purchasing decision. And with so many merchants offering free Read more »

John Bertrand Cognizant

Cryptocurrencies and the need for regulation

Anyone with a pulse and the money to cover legal fees can issue a cryptocurrency.  Once the cryptocurrency is created, however, brokers are needed to sell and make a market for it. Given cryptocurrencies are an unregulated market, then there are Read more »

Peter Groucutt Databarracks

New report suggests that UK government should regulate IoT: Comment from Databarracks

The content, guidelines and recommendations in the government’s recently introduced Code of Practice are excellent. It addresses the most fundamental cyber security practices in order of criticality and importance. But the scheme doesn’t prohibit Read more »

Related Blogs

Elina Mattila Mobey Forum

The Way You Make Me Feel – Highlights from Mobey Day 2018

Banking is not just about money. According to Lorenz Jüngling from The Isle Ventures, it is also about users and, most importantly, their emotions.  And, as Danske Bank’s Guri Hanstvedt commented, the power of emotions should not be underestimated. Read more »

André Stoorvogel Rambus

What is Card-on-file EMV Payment Tokenization?

The way we pay is changing. Consumers are now using their PC, smartphones, wearable devices and even cars to buy goods and services. The size and value of the card-not-present (CNP) market is increasing exponentially as payment use-cases across e- Read more »

Paul Sweetingham DXC Technology

Eight Must-haves When Choosing a Cards and Payments Services Provider

There are so many factors to consider when a business starts looking for a cards and payment services provider.  The new kids on the block, fintechs and start-ups, are challenging the norm, bringing technological customer expectations with them – Read more »

Ruben Salazar Visa Latin America and the Caribbean

Why Do Fast Transfers Work Better within Payment Networks?

Financial authorities and regulators around the globe are looking for new fast payment solutions. International card payment networks like Visa are already offering and expanding these solutions. Fast Transfers in payments networks are transactions Read more »

Center for Financial Professionals Center for Financial Professionals

The evolving payments landscape: Increasing competitiveness and upcoming regulatory deadlines

In recent years the payments landscape has evolved and transformed, in the near future it seems likely to continue to do so. 2018 is being seen as a watershed year in terms of regulatory implementation deadlines across the financial services space Read more »

Free Newsletter Sign-up
+44 (0) 208 819 32 53 +44 (0) 173 261 71 47
Download Our Mobile App