A Case for Regulatory Freeze?

A Case for Regulatory Freeze?

Christian Voigt

Senior Regulatory Adviser at Fidessa

Views 565

A Case for Regulatory Freeze?

29.06.2017 09:45 am

Market participants are naturally worried about the immediate costs of regulation, some of them still uncertain about the future benefits. But with all the twists and turns on the road to regulatory change, meeting the requirements imposed by regulators is no easy task.

Whatever the legislation, the politicians agree on the broad principles and set a go-live date and then the clock starts ticking to agree the finer details and deliver the software. But the approach that has typically been taken to regulatory change is flawed in many ways. While this is a general issue, it can be perfectly illustrated by MiFID II. As is so often the case, the political agreement hides some unresolved issues. Even three years after publishing the MiFID II Level 1 text, there is no certainty around what Direct Electronic Access means. Also, those Level 1 texts are a poor indicator of where the complexity really lies. For example, MiFID II Articles 57 & 58 appear straightforward enough, but have in fact triggered two of the most controversial and delayed technical standards (RTS 22 and 23). In spite of the one year extension of the original MiFID II implementation deadline, we’re still missing many of the details with less than 200 days until go-live. And just last week the European Commission re-opened a Level 2 text to change the rules around the Systematic Internaliser. As a consequence, any delivery schedule soon comes under serious pressure and IT teams are expected to start building systems while there is no market-wide agreement. This is like two heart surgeons discussing what to do after they’ve cut the patient open.

All of this translates into higher costs and greater complexity for the industry. While some initiatives look at streamlining regulation (for example, the CFTC’s Project KISS), we should also think about how to implement regulatory change itself in a more efficient and cost-effective way. So how about a regulatory change freeze – a fixed period where regulators don’t move the goal posts and firms can work toward a fully-defined set of detailed requirements for their IT departments. Too late for MiFID II, I know, but this approach will ultimately enable technology to deliver solutions faster and cheaper to the benefit of the industry and its regulators alike.

Latest blogs

Alex Malyshev SDK.finance

The Biggest Danger to Branchless Banking

With a third of the global population on lockdown and scores of bank branches closed, many are convinced that branch banking is dead, and the future is branchless. Is this really true? Branchless alternatives like Revolut, N26, Monzo, and NuBank Read more »

Dima Feldman and Aviv Castro Altair Semiconductor, a Sony Group Company

Constantly tracking anything, anywhere

The internet of things is changing the shape of many businesses. Not only does the IoT herald in greater visibility of production asset effectiveness, improve operational efficiencies, and facilitate more informed decision making, it is also Read more »

Francesca Campanelli Axyon AI

How Fund Managers Can Use AI to Retain Current Investors and Rebuild Client Confidence

After months of market volatility and challenging conditions, fund managers are starting to see a light at the end of the Covid-19 tunnel. Countries are starting to relax their lockdown measures and restart economies, with stock markets reacting Read more »

N/A ReliaMax

College Dreams? Here’s How to Get Accepted

Higher education in the United States is not just about getting accepted, it is about where you get accepted. Sure, there are options, there are seemingly endless options - from community colleges to Ivy League schools and everything in between. The Read more »

Bobby Gill GCWealth

Bobby Gill: 3 Ways Fintech is Helping Small Businesses During the Pandemic

Image Source: Pixabay. Back in April, the US oil prices sank to a 20-year low. In the UK, road traffic levels hit a 70-year low. Worldwide, due to lockdown, retail, travel, and restaurant bookings have dropped by 85%. More than 430 million Read more »

Related Blogs

Christian Voigt Fidessa

Who Makes the Decisions Around Here?

Recording the execution decision maker is a new requirement under MiFID II. Working out how to populate that field turns out to be trickier than expected. Read more »

Christian Voigt Fidessa

For Infosec the Only Way is Global

With information security rapidly gaining prominence over the last few years legislators have jumped into action to improve safeguards and public confidence in IT systems. While information security concerns prevail across all industries, in Read more »

Christian Voigt Fidessa

A Year to Go – More or Less

With just 364 days left to go, the MiFID II go-live date looms large. But with complex regulation spanning several hundred pages of text it is no great surprise that some MiFID II deadlines will come in earlier than 3rd January 2018, while others Read more »

Christian Voigt Fidessa

Golden Aspirations

To achieve MiFID II’s aim of greater transparency, having a proper golden source of instrument data is key for every market participant. Fortunately, under the new rules, ESMA is required to publish a list of all financial instruments traded on all Read more »

Christian Voigt Fidessa

Phew! No more HFT for me

Some might remember the surprise, back in March 2012, when it became apparent that an individual personal trader could end up being classed as a high frequency trader (HFT) under MiFID II. Admittedly I’m quite proud of my 10 finger touch-typing Read more »

Free Newsletter Sign-up
+44 (0) 208 819 32 53 +44 (0) 173 261 71 47
Download Our Mobile App
Financial It Youtube channel