Regulating fintech: Protecting the market without smothering innovation

Regulating fintech: Protecting the market without smothering innovation

Dave Lewis

Director at Alpha Insight

Views 393

Regulating fintech: Protecting the market without smothering innovation

25.01.2016 10:00 am

With a wealth of new ideas and innovation continually coming to market, the UK’s financial technology sector is a very exciting place to be. New start-ups are constantly emerging, causing incredible changes in the industry.

It’s perhaps not surprising then that many investors’ sights are set on London, a hub for financial services and technology innovation. Indeed, in 2014 alone, the UK government estimates the domestic financial technology sector attracted a massive £342 million in investment and generated £20 billion in revenue.

From new and more effective capabilities in monitoring major banks’ business flows, to peer-to-peer lending and apps that facilitate the transfer of small amounts of money between consumers, new companies are capitalising on the hybridisation of technology to develop and pioneer effective, time-saving solutions.

Meanwhile, household technology brands such as Apple are also prompting a step-change in the way consumers pay for goods and services with the launch of Apple Pay in the UK.

Yet, as more technology companies follow their lead and roll out financial services to an increasingly open-minded market, there is a clear need to protect consumers with no experience of new technology and where its potential pitfalls lie.

As the recent spate of headline corporate security breaches highlights, many users will willingly and trustingly subscribe to new services without knowing where their data is kept and who has access to it. In future, the use of decentralised digital currencies such as Bitcoin by newer companies will only add to these risks.

In addition to allegations of fraud and wrong-doing, failure of processes and systems – as experienced by RBS and HSBC in the UK this year – can do untold damage to reputation and is likely to result in official warnings from the regulator, with the possibility of weighty fines.

To protect businesses, consumers and the industry itself, it is clear then that the fintech sector is going to be subject to regulation. However, in order to strike the right balance between protection and innovation, it is worth considering whether the regulators need to be as heavy-handed as they currently are with banks.

In particular, there is industry-wide concern that the weight of regulation designed to prevent another financial crash or market-wrecking institutional failure is itself inhibiting the global efficiency and successful operation of banks.

To fulfil the requirements of new regulations such as BCBS239, for instance, major banks have to be incredibly rigorous in their reporting and demonstrate not only that they are achieving compliance but also provide evidence.

The best way to achieve this is to implement constant business flow monitoring and alerting based on the right business logic, allowing action to be taken to ensure compliance. However, this is something many organisations are still ill-equipped to do – despite the fact that the January 2016 deadline is just around the corner.

In protecting the consumers and organisations that use new and existing financial services, the risk, of course, is that regulation will stifle innovation. This is especially true in start-up hubs such as London that are attracted to the capital because they have access to the UK justice system and a vibrant domestic and international market, without the burden of legislation as seen across the different states in the US.

From an internal process perspective, this is something that could potentially be avoided in the first instance by having the right business logic on top of the monitoring tools.

Nevertheless, with public money and trust at stake, it is unavoidable that if the services provided by fintech firms include payments, they are going to be regulated in a similar way to banks.

While no-one wants excessive regulation or “regulatory principles” imposed on a company providing a new service that businesses and consumers want, whenever a consumer is involved, they must be protected. Most people accept that without independent regulation, the entire field is open to fraud and unfair exploitation.

With this in mind, the Financial Conduct Authority’s engagement in Project Innovate can only be seen as a good thing in that it seeks to encourage innovation by identifying and remedying policies that act as barriers.

By involving fintech companies, regulators and disinterested experts in the field, it offers a much more balanced approach and the potential to deliver the right outcome – for the consumer, the market and the UK economy.

Latest blogs

Hirander Misra GMEX Group

Are UK Banks profiting from the current coronavirus crisis and failing SMEs?

A UK business could be eligible for a Coronavirus Business Interruption Loan Scheme (CBILS), as set out by the UK Government. However, it appears that despite the Government’s best intentions, this scheme is not working in practice and some urgent Read more »

Otabek Nuritdinov Safenetpay

A strong fintech needs more than just access to funding

  Investors, both private and institutional, are excited about investing in fintechs that are in the payments services business. What are the issues that really should matter to you, as a client? In 2019, institutional investors Read more »

Martijn Bos Holland FinTech

Get your head up in the clouds, it’s good for business

How Digital Transformation is reshaping competition in financial services The message is clear and it’s coming at us from all sides: digitalize now. No business unit seems to be immune to the onslaught of cloud-based, AI-driven, real-time, Read more »

Sonny Aulakh Pure Storage

How to support remote working without compromising productivity

As the need to work remotely continues to impact the daily lives of people and businesses around the globe, it places unexpected demand on IT departments. How do you transition supporting 30% of your workforce to work remotely to 100% in a matter of Read more »

Martijn Bos Holland FinTech

Making it through the rain: Finance in times of turmoil

You’d need to be living on a remote island, without electricity or internet to not be aware of what the world is going through right now – a medical crisis that has spread across the world and disrupted supply chains, goods and services production, Read more »

Related Blogs

Huw Kwon Cognizant

Entity v process: The collective power of AI

Most, if not all, financial institutions are exploring how the range of new and emerging technologies collectively known as artificial intelligence (AI) can improve their performance across a range of activities and processes.  AI offers methods and Read more »

Will Hurst Monevo

How coronavirus is affecting the Fintech sector

Customer demand for credit won’t alter, in fact it’s likely to increase during times of economic uncertainty, says Will Hurst, Head of Commercial Development at Monevo. Will says Fintechs, such as Monevo, part of Quint Group, are well placed from an Read more »

Gemma Doswell Paybase

Paybase Predicts...

What we said in 2018 Read more »

Martijn Groot Asset Control

The Top Tips to Consider When Choosing the Right Fintech Partner – How to Get it Right

As banks and other financial services firms to look to strengthen their services and tackle increased competition from new rivals in banking and investment management, fintech partnerships are becoming increasingly popular across the industry. Read more »

Lina Andolf-Orup Fingerprints

Finger on the pulse! The Countdown to 2020 has Begun

With 2020 in sight, now is the perfect time to pause and reflect on the past three months and see how the world of biometrics has evolved since our last update. With everything from high profile announcements to some news you may not have heard, Q3 Read more »

Free Newsletter Sign-up
+44 (0) 208 819 32 53 +44 (0) 173 261 71 47
Download Our Mobile App
Financial It Youtube channel