A brief history of on/off-exchange

A brief history of on/off-exchange

Christian Voigt

Senior Regulatory Adviser at Fidessa

Christian is a Senior Regulatory Adviser at Fidessa. He focuses on the growing regulatory and functional requirements for multi-asset automated trading systems, supporting Fidessa's clients across Europe in meeting these challenges.

Views 546

A brief history of on/off-exchange

23.03.2016 08:45 am

Hailed by legislators as the new framework to close loopholes, MiFID II will see OTC trading face new restrictions, most importantly in the form of the Systematic Internaliser (SI) and the new trading obligations. As the fog slowly lifts, it’s becoming apparent that these new restrictions could impact market structure in surprising ways. A more detailed analysis shows that ETFs, ADRs and other similar financial instruments will face comparable requirements to equity shares. Whilst SIs are not attractive for derivatives that face the risk of a trading obligation, they might compete for market share in other non-equity instruments. And finally, OTC trading without an SI will be limited to a very small market share, irrespective of the asset class.

It’s perhaps premature to start drafting a eulogy for OTC markets, but what’s certain today is that the relationship between on- and off-exchange trading will become more intricate under MiFID II. Being a glass-half-full kind of guy I took great solace in reading Ranald C. Michie’s book, The Global Securities Market: A History, which tells us that the battle between competing sectors is nothing new. Michie tells the story of how the first formal stock exchange was founded in Paris in 1724 and immediately the market separated into “agents de change” (aka on-exchange) and an alternative market that flourished in the streets outside the exchange building (aka OTC) trying to avoid government imposed limitations. And he describes how in 1871 an OTC market developed in New York alongside the exchange because of disagreements on commission models.

So, even centuries ago, exchange and OTC markets have competed against each other on market quality, regulatory burden and cost. Any changes under MiFID II are merely one more chapter (and certainly not the last) in the long history of markets. The current regulators’ aims will undoubtedly be met, but we should also remember from past experience that markets have a tendency to rebalance and innovate.

Latest blogs

Nish Kotecha Finboot and Bryan Foss, NED, Visiting Professor at Bristol Business School and member of the FRC Audit & Assurance Council

How Listed Companies Can Use Blockchain to Prevent Auditing and Reporting Malpractice and Avoid Scandal

Not too long ago, there was very little to link Wirecard, the disgraced payments platform in Aschheim, Germany, with Boohoo, the fast-fashion online retailer in Leicester, England, but both have recently been embroiled in high-profile scandals. Read more »

Leon Muis Yolt Technology Services

The Time for Financial Services to Become Truly Digital is Now

The financial services industry looks set to change dramatically over the next couple of years in response to COVID-19. The pandemic has certainly highlighted some inefficiencies and weak spots in current processes for many businesses, such as those Read more »

Granville Turner Turner Little

The Lockdown Money Revolution

Many Brits have found that lockdown has been beneficial for their money, having cut back on personal spending and managing to put away some extra cash. According to eToro, Brits with unspent discretionary income are set to accumulate £75.5bn in Read more »

Sandra Higgins Sysnet Global Solutions

Are You ‘Prescribing’ the Right Security Solution to Your Merchants?

When it comes to leading a healthy lifestyle, eating the right food, taking regular exercise, and maintaining a positive mindset are key. However, despite these best intentions and practices, you still might not get all the nutrients your body needs Read more »

Robert Flowers DivideBuy

It Doesn’t Have to Be the End – How Retailers Can Grow in Light of COVID-19

It’s no news that the retail industry has been flipped on its head by the COVID-19 pandemic. Due to the lockdown, most in-store operations have been shut down, and nationwide furloughs, reduced pay and steady streams of income at risk have fuelled a Read more »

Free Newsletter Sign-up
+44 (0) 208 819 32 53 +44 (0) 173 261 71 47
Download Our Mobile App
Financial It Youtube channel