For All the Talk About Blockchain, What is Really Happening?

For All the Talk About Blockchain, What is Really Happening?

Chris Skinner

Chairman at The Financial Services Club

Views 313

For All the Talk About Blockchain, What is Really Happening?

18.05.2016 11:00 am

There is a lot of talk about blockchain.  A lot.  Loads.  But when you get past all the talk, what is actually happening with blockchain?  Answer: not enough.

I say this because there are some stand out firms out there – like R3, Digital Asset Holdings, Ripple – who have gained traction with the banks, but the banks are still unsure of their commitment to blockchain developments.  Talking with several, they see their commitment was funding these firms to do the work for them.  Now that they have funded, they feel that’s it.  Some are actually scaling back their internal blockchain developments on the basis that the industry needs to create the capabilities.  The problem with that view is there is no industry to create something.  Just a few major players who can push the button that the rest then need to follow.  That’s why the involvement of the JPMorgan’s and HSBC’s of this world in these early project developments was of interest, but now those commitments are in question.  I say this because of the lack of any real consortia to create a shared system and without sharing, blockchain developments will come to nought. After all, blockchain protocol is focused on building shared ledgers on the internet, and shared ledgers require the banks to come together to create shared structures.1  Unfortunately, from where I stand, the banks are not doing that.  I thought they were doing it with R3, and R3 is certainly developing something of interest, but there is already questions from some of the banks in the consortia about R3’s direction:

The questions about direction started when R3 announced Corda, their version of blockchain developed specifically for the banking system.  If you didn’t see the announcement at Money2020 in Copenhagen, then you can read more at R3’s CTO, Richard Gendal Brown’s blog.  In summary, what R3 announced is a new version of blockchain that keeps the best bits of the original protocol but has adapted it to meet the needs of complex counterparty clearing structures in the banking system.  The key features required by the banks include:

  • no unnecessary global sharing of data: only those parties with a legitimate need to know can see the data within an agreement
  • choreographed workflow between firms without a central controller
  • consensus between firms at the level of individual deals, not the level of the system
  • the design directly enables regulatory and supervisory observer nodes
  • transactions are validated by parties to the transaction, rather than a broader pool of unrelated validators
  • supports a variety of consensus mechanisms
  • records an explicit link between human-language legal prose documents and smart contract code
  • is built on industry-standard tools
  • has no native cryptocurrency

So the first question that comes to mind is: does the R3 Corda development negate all other blockchain-based developments in banking?  Does this destroy the Hyperledger Project  (no, as R3 is involved there too)?  What does it mean for Ethereum?  Will Ripple still make ripples?

My answer is that it is too early to tell, and we need to watch with caution the developing blockchain space in financial services.  In fact, having rocketed through the hype cycle during 2014-2015, it is my belief that blockchain has now entered the trough of disillusionment.  This is made clear when you realise that blockchain is like Big Data and Cloud.  A lot of talk, but little action at first.1

In fact, if I correlate blockchain with Cloud, it took a good seven years for Cloud discussions in banking to move from what the hell is it to I don’t trust this to does this make sense to ok, let’s create a cloud projectto shall we try this out to let’s implement cloud as it saves us millions.  For me, blockchain is in those early day sections of the bank.  Most bankers I talk to are trying ot get to grips with what the technology is and whether it makes sense, but few have reached the point of implementation or commitment.  Until they do, no shared ledger project is going to work as it needs a consortia of firms to make a banking blockchain structure work.  Once again, shared ledgers only work if they are shared.

This is when I come back to look at the key players who offer shared infrastructure already for the banks, such as the ECB and SWIFT.  The reality is that these organisations should be at the front-end charge of making blockchain work if it is going to succeed.  Yet neither organisation has yet made any key commitment to the technology, apart from SWIFT joining the Hyperledger Project.  However, this lackadaisical approach begs a critical question: if R3 develop the shared infrastructure using blockchain-based principles for the next generation financial system, will SWIFT or the ECB have a role in that new system?

Another big question raised in my mind recently is the real impact blockchain might have on our incumbent institutions.  Not the banks per se but the bank controllers.  Central banks and Central Counterparty Clearing systems surely become a bit of an anomaly in a decentralised world.  Can you still have central structures in a decentralised world?

Just wondering.

Latest blogs

Nish Kotecha and Noslen Suárez PhD Finboot

How blockchain can help us have trust in the food we eat

Today’s food supply chains are global, connected and generally efficient, but the COVID-19 pandemic has shone a spotlight on areas of weakness. The urgent need for robust and resilient systems and processes has been brought sharply into focus, and Read more »

Chris Miller RSA Security

Back to Normality: Five Steps to Stay Resilient After Disruption

The financial services sector has lived through many global disruptions, but the nature of recent events has put an unprecedented strain on operational resilience; from needing to ensure critical functions could continue with skeleton staff and Read more »


How Technology Has Disrupted the Used Car Buying Experience

We’ve seen many fields change rapidly as a result of the integration of modern technological advancements over the last couple of decades. And it looks like more is coming on the horizon as well, judging by current trends. One of the markets that Read more »

Shuvo G. Roy Mphasis

Reboot 1.0: How financial services technology can enable the supply chain to support a post-lockdown boom

Ground control and Captain Tom When veteran Captain Tom Moore decided to walk one hundred laps of his garden before his 100th birthday to raise funds to support NHS heroes battling Covid-19 from the frontline, he never imagined that he would Read more »

Lisa Gutu Salt Edge

Building a PSD2 compliant channel: challenges and opportunities for financial institutions

PSD2 obliges ASPSPs including banks, e-wallets, prepaid cards and other companies that offer payment accounts to provide at least one channel for secure communication with third party providers (TPP). Even neobanks or e-money institutions, including Read more »

Related Blogs

Nish Kotecha and Noslen Suárez PhD Finboot

How blockchain can help us have trust in the food we eat

Today’s food supply chains are global, connected and generally efficient, but the COVID-19 pandemic has shone a spotlight on areas of weakness. The urgent need for robust and resilient systems and processes has been brought sharply into focus, and Read more »

Christa Ardley Bitstocks

Bitcoin and blockchain without the b******t

An industry once viewed by the general populace as a haven for criminals and online scammers, and still somewhat marred by fractious in-fighting, Bitcoin and blockchain are gradually casting off their outdated negative reputation; as the focus Read more »

Angel Pateiro Finboot

How blockchain can resolve the data privacy threats posed by contact tracing

Two of the world’s largest tech giants, Apple and Google, recently announced that they are collaborating on a COVID-19 tracking system to enable contact tracing - a measure that could pave the way for an exit strategy for those countries enforcing Read more »

Juan Miguel Pérez Finboot

How to enhance and optimise data management with blockchain

Efficient data management has long been a cornerstone for any organisation and a way to generate valuable insights that can improve the corporate decision-making process. In the past few years, the focus on big data has resulted in an exponential Read more »

Juan Miguel Pérez Finboot

As airlines continue to suffer at hands of coronavirus, how can they look to blockchain to save money?

These past few weeks have been flooded with news of COVID-19 (“coronavirus”), with the consequences of this epidemic going far beyond health issues. Businesses in multiple sectors globally are suffering, but few have been as severely affected as the Read more »

Free Newsletter Sign-up
+44 (0) 208 819 32 53 +44 (0) 173 261 71 47
Download Our Mobile App
Financial It Youtube channel