The Surveillance Conundrum: Is My Surveillance Process Good Enough?

The Surveillance Conundrum: Is My Surveillance Process Good Enough?

Alistair Downes

Vice President of Product at Red Deer

Views 547

The Surveillance Conundrum: Is My Surveillance Process Good Enough?

25.11.2019 09:30 am

How to develop a practical approach to the surveillance challenge facing compliance and control professionals at global asset managers and hedge funds.

Every compliance officer lives with the knowledge that something can always get through the net. Despite advancing techniques used to capture, process and analyse trading, no surveillance process will ever be perfect, so the challenge is to build a sound and demonstrable process that can withstand scrutiny from investors, colleagues and regulators alike. As scrutiny from investors and regulators increases, compliance teams are left pondering “how do we know our surveillance process is good enough?” Then, as regulation and the firm’s trading change over time, the question becomes “how do we keep our surveillance processes good enough?”

Accepting the axiom that no process is perfect means accepting that your existing approach has weaknesses and gaps. That implies a required assessment of these gaps and a realistic plan of tactical and strategic steps to address them. As a result of recent changes in regulatory guidance (FCA Market Watch 56 to 60 and the SEC’s recent focus on MNPI and electronic communications), it’s become evident that firms do not currently have these plans in place, and often they have accepted a temporary and manual solution to the problem that is neither sound nor demonstrable. This presents a challenge, and the solution is a change in approach.

The following steps will help you develop and maintain an effective and defensible surveillance approach for your firm:

​1. Establish - in plain language - risks, policies and processes

The initial focus should be on establishing a shared understanding. The communication of risks, policies and processes in plain English enables constructive discussion amongst peers, illustration to investors, and concise response to regulatory queries. As businesses evolve, clear and repeated communication of policy and process will ensure collective buy-in and understanding, which increases the likelihood that potential gaps will be identified and reduced.

Recommended actions:

  • Run a comprehensive, bottom-up risk assessment covering regulatory and internal requirements
  • Identify units of risk (for example: email communications, trade activity, external phone calls)
  • Develop policies mitigating the identified units of risk
  • Link the policies to processes where applicable
  • Generate rules based on the processes

2. Once policies, processes, and rules are established, aggregate into a single surveillance system

A single surveillance system, implemented well, can explain existing and previous policies and their processes, changes to them, and provide an audit trail, which serves as justification and a path to soundness and defensibility, should the regulator request a review.

3. Automate as much as possible

With that done, the final step is to define an internal flow of publishing, challenge, and review of cases - to provide firm-wide visibility and understanding. Done correctly, this process can be almost fully automated, taking the form of emailed review reminders, scheduled reporting and internal surveys, which, when combined with the detailed audit, complete the evolution to a sound and demonstrable surveillance approach.


-     Alert generation and resulting activities

  • Periodic policy reviews
  • Management information reporting
  • Internal firm survey

The Result

The result is a well-understood surveillance approach, supported by detail and audit covering all decisions, reviews, and changes in one automated system; reduced overhead in spite of an increase in regulatory oversight; and, finally, an answer of yes to the questions “is this good enough?” and “will it remain so?”

Latest blogs

Nish Kotecha and Noslen Suárez PhD Finboot

How blockchain can help us have trust in the food we eat

Today’s food supply chains are global, connected and generally efficient, but the COVID-19 pandemic has shone a spotlight on areas of weakness. The urgent need for robust and resilient systems and processes has been brought sharply into focus, and Read more »

Chris Miller RSA Security

Back to Normality: Five Steps to Stay Resilient After Disruption

The financial services sector has lived through many global disruptions, but the nature of recent events has put an unprecedented strain on operational resilience; from needing to ensure critical functions could continue with skeleton staff and Read more »


How Technology Has Disrupted the Used Car Buying Experience

We’ve seen many fields change rapidly as a result of the integration of modern technological advancements over the last couple of decades. And it looks like more is coming on the horizon as well, judging by current trends. One of the markets that Read more »

Shuvo G. Roy Mphasis

Reboot 1.0: How financial services technology can enable the supply chain to support a post-lockdown boom

Ground control and Captain Tom When veteran Captain Tom Moore decided to walk one hundred laps of his garden before his 100th birthday to raise funds to support NHS heroes battling Covid-19 from the frontline, he never imagined that he would Read more »

Lisa Gutu Salt Edge

Building a PSD2 compliant channel: challenges and opportunities for financial institutions

PSD2 obliges ASPSPs including banks, e-wallets, prepaid cards and other companies that offer payment accounts to provide at least one channel for secure communication with third party providers (TPP). Even neobanks or e-money institutions, including Read more »

Related Blogs

Christopher Monaco Seismic

Can Content Automation End the Quarterly Update Crisis?

With global outflows on the rise and industry consolidation becoming increasingly common, it’s critical for asset management firms to foster productivity in conjunction with improving operational efficiency. Read more »

Christopher Monaco Seismic Software

Managing Expectations in an Indefinite Financial Services World

One of the best visuals juxtaposing expectations against reality takes place within what is widely considered a masterful scene in the adored romantic comedy 500 Days of Summer. Cinematic digression aside, such a balancing act is not only an Read more »

Christopher Monaco Seismic Software

Technological Trends in Asset Management: The Growth of Blockchain

The proverbial table for asset management’s evolution has been set for quite a while. Some would say what started with the financial and regulatory effects of the Great Recession has now bubbled to the surface, manifesting itself in the form of high Read more »

Christopher Monaco Seismic Software

An Active Strategy for Passive Investing

Much like robo advisors have done in the area of wealth management, passive asset management and the products associated with it are gaining in popularity among investors, putting further pressure on active managers to beat the market and generate Read more »

Steve Grob Group Strategy, Fidessa

Too big to fail or too big to succeed?

Interesting to see that Martin Wheatley, head of the FCA, is siding with the largest asset managers in their push back against the Financial Stability Board. The basic idea is that because of their size, global regulators want to deem them “ Read more »

Free Newsletter Sign-up
+44 (0) 208 819 32 53 +44 (0) 173 261 71 47
Download Our Mobile App
Financial It Youtube channel